Christine McCormick | Email
P: (845) 446-4280 x323
F: (845) 446-3853
Eve Weyant | Email
P: (845) 446-4280 x322
F: (845) 446-3853
Deborah MacLeod | Email
P: (845) 446-4280 x333
F: (845) 446-3853
Monday - Friday 8am - 4:30pm
Closed for lunch: 1pm-2pm
Town of Highlands Justice Court
254 Main Street – POB 277
Highland Falls, New York 10928
The Town of Highlands Justice Court adjudicates criminal, vehicle and traffic, landlord-tenant and civil matters as well as Town and Village Code and most Environmental Law violations. Please use the tabs below to navigate for details on each matter.
Town of Highlands Justice Court
254 Main Street – POB 277
Highland Falls, New York 10928
Town of Highlands Former Judges
From left to right: William desRosiers, Gary Lent, Konstantinos Fatsis, Vincent Donaldson, Charles Quaintance, and Ned Kopald.
Criminal Court Dockets are typically heard on the first and third Tuesdays of every month. Court begins either at 10:00am or at 7:00pm. If you are not sure about your court date, please contact the court office during hours of operation to confirm. Adjournments are typically not given for criminal court. If you request an adjournment, it must be at least 7 days before your court date and in writing by mail or fax along with documented evidence of your reason, for example a detailed doctor’s letter, or travel/airline tickets, etc.
The Town of Highlands Justice Court has criminal jurisdiction over misdemeanor offenses, (crimes which are punishable by up to 1 (one) year in jail) occurring in the confines of the Town of Highlands. The Court also has jurisdiction over felony cases for the purposes of conducting a preliminary hearing, setting bail and arraignments only. Once the matter is held for the action of the Orange County Grand Jury, after the preliminary hearing, the Court is divested of jurisdiction and the case is transferred to the County Court for further proceedings including trial.
If you are arrested for misdemeanor traffic violations, i.e. DWI, Aggravated Unlicensed Operation, etc. you are to report to the Court on the date specified on the Appearance Ticket issued to you. Do not mail in a plea for misdemeanor traffic violations.
Contact Information for Criminal Case Legal Agencies
Orange County District Attorney:
Middletown Branch Office 845-615-3640
Newburgh Branch Office 845-568-5050
Goshen Branch Office 845-291-2050
Orange County Legal Aid
Goshen Office 845-291-2454
Vehicle & Traffic Court Dockets are typically heard every Wednesday of every month. Court begins either at 10:00am or at 7:00pm. If you are not sure about your court date, please contact the court office during hours of operation to confirm. If you request an adjournment, it must be at least 7 days before your court date and in writing by mail or fax along with documented evidence of your reason, for example a detailed doctor’s letter, or travel/airline tickets, etc.
The Town of Highlands Justice Court has jurisdiction over vehicle & traffic offenses committed within the Town of Highlands.
Non-criminal traffic infractions may be answered by mail. Please enter your plea in the appropriate box on the summons and mail to the Court by the date on the bottom of the summons. PLEASE INCLUDE YOUR CURRENT MAILING ADDRESS AND A PHONE NUMBER SO THE COURT CAN CONTACT YOU IF NECESSARY.
If you are pleading GUILTY, you will be sent a fine letter. Check the Payment of Fines Screen for methods of payment.
If you are pleading NOT GUILTY, you will receive a notice with a Pre-Trial Conference Date for you to appear.
Suspensions: If you receive a suspension notice from the NYSDMV, you must answer that notice before the suspension date listed. Failure to have that notice to the Court before that suspension date will require that the motorist pay a non-refundable, NYSDMV state-mandated suspension lift fee for each ticket in addition to any fines that may be due. Return the whole suspension notice to the Court, do not tear off any portion. The notice will be signed, sealed and returned to you as your proof of the suspension lift. PLEASE NOTE THAT SUSPENSIONS OCCUR AT 12:01AM ON THE SPECIFIED SUSPENSION DATE.
Parking tickets: Fines may be paid in person during office hours by Cash and Master/Visa Credit or Debits cards. If you are paying by credit/debit card, the card must be yours and you will be asked for identification – the Court will not accept a signature of anyone but the cardholder. If you are mailing in a payment, only money orders or bank certified checks are accepted. THE COURT DOES NOT ACCEPT PERSONAL CHECKS. Parking tickets cannot be paid online.
Vehicle & Traffic Violations: Fines may be paid in person during office hours by Cash and Master/Visa Credit or Debits cards. If you are paying by credit/debit card, the card must be yours and you will be asked for identification – the Court will not accept a signature of anyone but the cardholder. If you are mailing in a payment, only money orders or bank certified checks are accepted. THE COURT DOES NOT ACCEPT PERSONAL CHECKS. Payments may be made online at www.paycourtonline.com or by calling 1-888-912-1541. You will need your case or ticket number as part of your identifying information. This is a service provided by a company other than the court and a convenience fee is applied.
Criminal Fines and Surcharges: Fines may be paid in person during office hours by Cash and Master/Visa Credit or Debits cards. If you are paying by credit/debit card, the card must be yours and you will be asked for identification – the Court will not accept a signature of anyone but the cardholder. If you are mailing in a payment, only money orders or bank certified checks are accepted. THE COURT DOES NOT ACCEPT PERSONAL CHECKS. Payments may be made online at www.paycourtonline.com or by calling 1-888-912-1541. You will need your case or ticket number as part of your identifying information. This is a service provided by a company other than the court and a convenience fee is applied.
If you are making a payment by mail and would like a receipt of your payment, please enclose a self-addressed, stamped envelope.
$10.00 – Filing Fee to the Court (for claims up to and including $1,000)
$15.00 – Filing Fee to the Court (for claims up to and including $3,000)
$20.00 – Filing Fee for Civil Court - It is the responsibility of the plaintiff to prepare Paperwork and have it served.
Fees are payable at the time of filing. Landlord/Tenant cases are typically heard every Wednesday and Small Claim/Civil Actions typically heard the second and fourth Wednesdays of every month. Before filing any paperwork for a Landlord-Tenant Matter call the Court for our scheduled docket dates.
Unrepresented New Yorkers may go to NYCourthelp.gov to find forms for some Civil Matters.
What is a Small Claim?
A Small Claim is a claim for money only, not exceeding $3,000, where the person you wish to sue either lives, works, or has a place of business within the Town of Highlands, (including corporations). No partnership, association, corporation or assignee, except a municipal corporation, public benefit corporation, school district or public library, may bring an action in the small claims part of a justice court. Such cases must be brought in the civil part of the court which is subject to different rules. A corporation may appear in defense of any small claim action brought pursuant to this article by an attorney, as well as, by an authorized officer, director or employee of the corporation. The appearance of any officer, director or employee of the corporation will be deemed to constitute authority on the part of that person to bind the corporation to a settlement or at trial.
While you do not need a lawyer in small claims cases, in the Town of Highlands, you may retain an attorney if you so desire. If you retain an attorney and the case is not settled, the actual trial may be in the daytime. The return date contained in the Small Claims Notice is the Trial Date and you should be prepared to present your case or defense.
Sue the Correct Party
An employee or an owner(shareholder) of a corporation is not normally the person liable for the debts or actions of the corporation or company. The corporation or company should be named as a defendant to be certain that the judgment will be issued against the correct party. If the wrong party is named and served, the case may have to be dismissed and you may have to start your action again. It is suggested that all parties who are, or may be liable be named in the summons. You may have to locate the true name by searching at the County Clerk's office for Business Certificates or corporation filings to obtain the true party.
Getting Ready for Trial
On the trial date, you must be present in Court with your witnesses, your account books, receipts, records and other documents that are relevant to your case. It has been the experience of the Judges of the Court that many claims are lost and cases dismissed because of the plaintiffs' and defendants' failure to produce proper and legally sufficient proof and evidence.
After you have filed your Small Claim with the Clerk, you should use the time between the filing and the actual trial date to gather together all of your documentary evidence and to arrange to have any and all witnesses present at the trial. This is your case and it is your responsibility to prepare it properly. The Court is not permitted to help you prove your case because the Court must remain fair and impartial and cannot help either the plaintiff or the defendant with their presentation.
Suggestion: Bring photocopies of your records and other proof for the Court and make copies for your opponent. A final word of advice is that preparation is the key to presenting your case which is true, even for attorneys and you would save yourself and the Court time, if you are able to narrow the issues when you appear in front of the Judge. For example, you need not use several photos depicting the same image when one will suffice. Write out questions you intend to ask your opponent or witnesses, organize your thoughts and questions in a chronological order so the facts are made clear to the Judge.
Written testimony or affidavits, letters or statements from 3rd parties are not admissible in Court.
The Trial: Procedure and Order
Make sure you bring with you the original and two copies of any bills or estimates, as well as contracts, photographs and any other documentation or evidence which you desire to introduce at trial. Trial may not be adjourned in order to allow either party to produce a document or other item of proof which they neglected or forgot to bring to trial, without good reason.
If the matter goes to trial, the plaintiff presents his/her case first. As plaintiff, you should tell your story clearly. You should have some notes to refresh your recollection and it is usually best to start with the first event relevant to your case and proceed in chronological order. All witnesses including the plaintiff and defendant shall testify under oath, and may be subject to cross-examination by the opposing party. After the plaintiff's case is completed, the defendant, will present his/her case and may then take the witness stand and/or call witnesses to testify.
During the entire process the judge will ask you questions. After both sides have completed their case the Judge may make a decision right on the spot or he may settle the case if both sides agree at that time, or he may reserve decision and you will receive a written decision in the mail sometime later.
Use of Attorneys
If your case is complicated, either by facts or legal issues, it might be wise to consult an attorney, and have him/her represent you at trial.
Coming to Court on the Trial Date
You must come to court either to prove or defend the case. If you do not appear at the time set for the hearing, the Court will dismiss your claim if you are the plaintiff, or may grant default judgment against you if you are the defendant and take an inquest to determine the amount of the judgment.
There are certain circumstances under which a default can be re-opened, but they are complicated and normally require you to hire an attorney. It should also be noted that not all defaults are vacated so it is important that you appear in Court, whenever scheduled.
Defendants in Small Claims Cases
As a defendant you can also make a counterclaim. It cannot exceed $3,000 in amount. A counterclaim must be filed with the Court within 5 days of receiving the claim, and you must pay a fee of $3.00 plus cost of mailing.
If you cannot appear on the date for trial, you must request an adjournment well in advance of the trial date. If you know well enough in advance, you may write a letter to the Clerk of the Court, and send a copy of the letter to your opponent. If it is too late to write a letter, you must have someone appear for you in Court and give the same information to the Judge. If you do not appear or if your excuse is unsatisfactory or if you have failed to advise your opponent, the Court may dismiss your case, if you are the plaintiff, or grant a default judgment against you if you are the defendant.
All parties are encouraged to settle their disputes prior to trial whenever possible. If both parties agree to settle the case prior to trial, the Court should be advised by the plaintiff that the case is settled and the amount agreed upon for our records to avoid coming to Court.
If the case is settled prior to trial and the payment is not forthcoming, the case can be rescheduled for trial. All cases settled either before trial or at trial are contingent upon the payment being made. A case may be settled by stipulation, which is an agreement between both sides made in or out of court, and if out of court it must be signed by both parties and filed with the Court, to be enforced later. If the amount agreed upon is not paid, then the court will issue a judgment.
After the decision is rendered you have 30 days to appeal. If you decide to appeal, you must file a Notice of Appeal and a $5 fee with the Court and serve the Notice of Appeal upon the other party and file an Affidavit of Service.
Information required for Small Claims Summons:
1. Name of Defendant
2. Address of Defendant
3. Name of Plaintiff
4. Amount of money which you seek (maximum of $3000)
5. A clear and concise statement in layman's language of the basis for your claim
6. Address of Plaintiff, day-time phone number for plaintiff
Proper attire and decorum are required within the court at all times. Proper attire does not include the following: shorts, mini-skirts, tank tops, flip-flops, torn and tattered clothing and any other clothing that may be deemed inappropriate within the discretion of the court. There will be no talking or disruptive behavior tolerated within the courtroom or adjoining areas. Gum chewing, eating or drinking is strictly prohibited.
Cell phones, cameras, computers and electronic devices of any nature ARE NOT allowed in the building. In addition, weapons of any kind are not permitted within the courtroom or adjoining areas by anyone other than law enforcement and/or court personnel. If any weapon is found on your possession, you may be subject to arrest and prosecution.
For the convenience of Jurors, a call-in service is in effect. Call 845-446-4280 x322 after 5pm on the day before the date of trial indicated to verify the need for your appearance.
Pursuant to the Constitution of the United States of America, it is your responsibility as a citizen to serve. It is a privilege and honor to serve as a juror, but we are aware that this service may cause great inconvenience and even hardship. The service rendered is critical to our community since it sets the moral tone and standards by which we all must abide. We thank you for giving your time and serving in this capacity.
If you claim an exemption or excusal, you must notify this Court in writing by mailing a letter with a copy of your notice to the Court at least 5 days before the date you are to appear, along with documented evidence for your reason for example a detailed doctor’s note or travel/airline tickets.